Back to blog

Compare Website Screenshots Without Misleading Crops

Photo comparisons3 min read

Prepare comparable before-and-after website captures, choose horizontal or vertical output, and label versions without hiding the change.

Maintained by Merge Two ImagesUpdated

A website comparison can make a redesign look more dramatic simply by changing browser width or page state. To show the actual interface changes, capture the same content under comparable conditions before joining the images. For room, repair, and photographic comparisons, use the broader before-and-after image guide.

Make the two captures comparable

Record the viewport width, browser zoom, page URL, and relevant state. For example, compare the same product page at the same desktop width, with the same accordion open and the same consent banner state. Avoid capturing one page at the top and the other after a scroll unless scrolling is the change you want to explain.

Use the same capture method for both versions. Browser chrome, operating-system scaling, and device pixel ratio can make screenshot pixel dimensions differ from the viewport's CSS dimensions. Check the actual files rather than assuming that a 1200px viewport always produces a 1200px-wide image.

If the old screenshot already exists and cannot be recreated, disclose the difference in the caption. Do not crop away missing content from the new page merely to suggest the two versions are equivalent.

Build a measurable comparison

For two prepared 1200 × 800 screenshots:

  1. Open the homepage merger and add the earlier capture first.
  2. Choose Horizontal, Original sizing, and a Free aspect ratio.
  3. Set spacing to 16px, outside margin to 0, and border to 0.
  4. Download PNG and check for 2416 × 800 pixels, assuming no smaller output limit is configured.

A Vertical layout with those same inputs is 1200 × 1616. At a 360px display width, the horizontal comparison shows each screenshot at about 179px wide; the vertical comparison shows each at 360px wide. Vertical therefore gives small interface labels more display width, while requiring more scrolling.

Label the versions after merging

Open the downloaded comparison in Add Text. Add short single-line labels such as “Version 1 · March” and “Version 2 · June” using your real version names and dates. Put labels over quiet space, leaving changed controls visible. The text tool does not add a margin strip automatically; prepare extra space in the merger if the screenshot has no suitable area.

The template editor also saves annotations in its PNG export. If you use it, check its 800-pixel template limit against the detail your comparison needs. Save the labeled file and reopen it to confirm the words are present.

Describe what the image can establish

Visible differenceUseful caption detailWhat still needs other evidence
Navigation rearrangedWhich links moved and whyWhether users find pages faster
Form shortenedWhich fields were removedWhether completion improved
New responsive layoutCapture width and device contextBehavior at other widths
Visual restylingTypography, spacing, and color changesAccessibility or performance results

An image can show the interface state. It cannot by itself prove higher conversion, faster loading, or better accessibility. Link to measurements or tests separately if those are part of the redesign claim. Put the explanation in surrounding page text so readers do not have to infer every change from the pixels.